Name: Classic Egg Salad
Prep time: 10 min
Cook time: 15 min
Total time: 25 min
Ingredients: 8 large eggs; ½ cup mayonnaise; 1½ tsp Dijon mustard; 1 celery rib, finely chopped; 1 scallion, thinly sliced; 2 tsp fresh dill (or ½ tsp dried); Salt and black pepper, to taste

My youngest asked for egg salad sandwiches on the last day of school, and I stood there at the counter realizing I hadn’t made a batch since the previous spring. Some recipes are like that.

They disappear for months and then someone asks, and you remember exactly why you keep coming back.

Egg salad is one of those dishes that looks simple enough to wing, but the eggs really do make or break it. Get them right and the whole thing comes together in minutes.

Rush the cooking or skip the ice bath, and you’re fighting rubbery whites and a greenish ring around the yolk before you’ve even touched the mayo.

This version uses fresh dill, a little Dijon, and finely chopped celery. It’s the one I’ve made more times than I can count.

Prep: 10 minutes · Cook: 15 minutes · Total: about 35 minutes (with cooling) · Serves: 4

↓ Jump to the recipe

How do you make egg salad that isn’t watery or rubbery?

Cook the eggs just until the yolks are fully set, then move them straight into an ice bath for 5 minutes to stop the cooking. Chop the celery very fine so it blends into the dressing instead of releasing water. Use enough mayo to coat, but don’t go so heavy that the salad turns loose and wet.

Why This Recipe Works

An ice bath after cooking stops the eggs from overcooking in their own residual heat, which is what causes that gray-green ring around the yolk and rubbery whites.
Finely chopped celery gives the salad a little crunch without releasing large pockets of water the way coarse pieces do, and it spreads cleanly on bread.
Starting with cold eggs straight from the fridge and lowering them into already-boiling water gives you a consistent cook time every single batch.

I skipped the ice bath the first couple of times I made this, thinking it was an extra step I didn’t need. The yolks were fine but the whites had that slightly tough, bouncy texture.

Five minutes in cold water costs nothing and it genuinely fixes it.

Why I Keep Coming Back to This One

Ready in about 35 minutes, most of which is hands-off cooling time
Five pantry and fridge staples, nothing you’d have to hunt for
Makes ahead beautifully, so Monday lunches are already handled on Sunday
Works on sandwiches, crackers, lettuce cups, or straight out of the bowl with a fork

What You’ll Need

8 large eggs
½ cup mayonnaise
1½ tsp Dijon mustard
1 celery rib, finely chopped
1 scallion, thinly sliced
2 tsp fresh dill (or ½ tsp dried)
Salt and black pepper, to taste

Ingredient Notes

Mayonnaise is the backbone of the dressing, so use one you actually like eating on its own. Full-fat works best here.

A reduced-fat version tends to be thinner and can make the salad watery as it sits in the fridge.

Dijon mustard adds a little sharpness that keeps the dressing from tasting flat. Regular yellow mustard works in a pinch, but it’s milder and sweeter, so the flavor shifts noticeably.

Either way, start with the amount in the recipe and taste before you add more.

Fresh dill is worth it if you can find it. It’s brighter and a little grassy in a way dried dill can’t quite match.

If you’re using dried, Once Upon a Chef and Spend With Pennies both call for fresh in their versions, with dried as a backup at roughly a quarter of the fresh amount, so ½ tsp dried for this batch.

How I Make It

Boil the water. Fill a medium saucepan with enough water to cover the eggs by an inch, and bring it to a full rolling boil over high heat. You want the water at a real boil before the eggs go in, not just steaming.
Cook the eggs. Lower the eggs gently into the boiling water one at a time using a slotted spoon, then reduce the heat to a steady simmer. Cook until the whites are fully set and the yolks are just cooked through with no translucent center, about 12 to 14 minutes.
Ice bath the eggs. Transfer the eggs immediately to a bowl of ice water and let them sit for 5 minutes, until the shells feel cool to the touch all the way around. This is the step that stops the cooking and makes the shells release cleanly from the whites.
Peel and chop. Peel the eggs under a thin stream of cool running water, which helps the shell slip off without tearing the white. Chop them into rough pieces, somewhere between a fine mince and a chunky dice, until no piece is larger than about half an inch.
Mix the dressing. In a medium bowl, stir together the mayonnaise, Dijon, celery, scallion, and dill until evenly combined. The mixture should look thick and hold its shape on a spoon before the eggs go in.
Fold in the eggs. Add the chopped eggs to the bowl and fold gently with a rubber spatula until everything is coated. Taste, then season with salt and black pepper. The egg salad is ready to eat right away, but it’s even better after 20 minutes in the fridge, once the flavors settle together.

Tips for Success

Don’t skip the ice bath. It takes 5 minutes and it’s the single biggest difference between eggs that peel cleanly and eggs that tear apart in your hand.
Chop the celery as fine as you can manage. Coarse pieces make the salad hard to spread on bread and give it an uneven texture.
I still don’t measure the dill, and I’m not going to start. Start with the recipe amount and add more if you want a stronger herb flavor.
The FDA recommends not leaving mayo-dressed dishes at room temperature for more than 2 hours, so keep this covered and refrigerated when it’s not being served.
If the salad looks a little dry after a night in the fridge, stir in a small spoonful of mayo to bring it back together. It loosens right up.
Yellow mustard, whole grain mustard, or even a small spoonful of pickle relish all work as swaps if you don’t have Dijon on hand.

Make-Ahead and Leftovers

Keep egg salad in a tightly covered container in the refrigerator. Spend With Pennies says it keeps well for up to 4 days, and Once Upon a Chef puts the ceiling at about 3 days.

I go with 3 days to be safe, and I’ve never had a batch last longer than that anyway. Egg salad does not freeze well.

The mayo breaks and the egg whites turn spongy when thawed, and there’s no fixing it after that. Don’t try it.

You can make this a day ahead and it actually improves overnight. The dill and mustard have time to work into the dressing and the whole thing tastes more pulled-together than a fresh batch.

What to Serve With Egg Salad

Toasted white or wheat sandwich bread, because the slight crunch holds up against the creamy filling without going soggy as fast as soft bread does
Butter crackers or sturdy water crackers, which make this a quick no-cook lunch that’s easy to pack
Romaine or butter lettuce leaves as a wrap, a lighter option that still gives you something to hold onto
Sliced tomatoes on the side, since the acidity cuts through the richness of the mayo dressing
A simple green salad with a vinegar-based dressing, which balances the richness of the egg salad without competing with it

Equipment Worth Having

A medium saucepan, large enough to hold 8 eggs in a single layer with an inch of water above them
A slotted spoon, for lowering the eggs into boiling water without cracking them on the bottom of the pan
A medium mixing bowl, glass or ceramic, big enough to fold the eggs in without everything spilling over the sides
A rubber spatula, which lets you fold gently without mashing the egg pieces into a paste
A sharp chef’s knife and a cutting board, because a dull knife drags and tears the egg whites instead of cutting cleanly

Your Questions, Answered

Can you make egg salad the night before? Yes, and it’s actually better the next day. The flavors come together as it sits, and the dressing thickens slightly. Keep it covered in the fridge and give it a stir before serving.

Why does my egg salad get watery? The most common reason is coarsely chopped celery, which releases water as it sits. Chop it very fine and the problem mostly disappears. Overcooked eggs can also weep a little, which is another reason the ice bath matters.

How long does egg salad last in the fridge? Spend With Pennies says up to 4 days, and Once Upon a Chef puts it at about 3 days. Keep it in a tightly sealed container and don’t leave it out at room temperature for more than 2 hours, per FDA food safety guidance.

Can you use miracle whip instead of mayonnaise? You can, but it’s sweeter and tangier than mayo, so the flavor of the whole salad shifts. If that’s what you have, start with a little less than the recipe calls for and taste as you go.

What’s the best way to peel hard-boiled eggs? Peel them under a thin stream of cool running water right after the ice bath. The water gets under the membrane and the shell comes off in bigger pieces instead of tiny shards.

Keep Cooking